Pilot First, Prove Later: Why Small Businesses Are Betting on AI Agents Before the ROI Arrives

AI agents are software systems that plan and carry out multistep tasks with limited human input. Surveys from 2025 and 2026 show that small and mid-sized companies are running agent pilots even though most organisations have not yet measured a financial return.

Small Businesses Testing Agents

The Upwork Research Institute surveyed 750 U.S. business leaders, including 195 at companies with 10 to 99 employees. TechInformed reported the results on June 25, 2026.

Agent pilots currently running at these smaller companies:

  • decision support: 41%;
  • information retrieval: 36%;
  • workflow automation: 34%;
  • multistep planning across systems: 34%.

Only 2% to 3% of these leaders are not considering each use.

  • Confidence: 62% are very or extremely confident handing high-stakes tasks to AI agents.
  • Strategy: 32% call agents mission-critical to company strategy.
  • Results: 74% report productivity gains from AI, but most gains are below 25%.
  • Barriers: data privacy and security is the top barrier (49%); uncertainty about return on investment is a barrier for 24%.

Upwork describes these leaders as “operating on conviction while they wait for major productivity gains.”

Why the ROI Lags

MIT NANDA, “The GenAI Divide: State of AI in Business 2025” (July 2025):

  • 95% of organisations get no measurable business return from $30–40 billion of company spending on generative AI.
  • The study reviewed more than 300 public AI initiatives, 52 interviews and 153 survey responses.
  • Of organisations that evaluated enterprise-grade AI systems, 60% looked at one, 20% reached a pilot and 5% reached production.
  • Tools bought from specialist vendors succeed about 67% of the time; tools built in-house succeed about one-third as often.
  • Mid-sized companies move from pilot to full rollout in about 90 days; large companies take nine months or longer.

Gartner (June 25, 2025):

  • More than 40% of agentic AI projects will be cancelled by the end of 2027 because of rising costs, unclear business value or weak risk controls.
  • Only about 130 of the thousands of vendors selling “agentic AI” offer genuine agent products; Gartner calls the relabelling of older products “agent washing”.
  • By 2028, 15% of day-to-day work decisions will be made autonomously by AI agents, up from 0% in 2024.

Betting Before the Evidence

Executive surveys show investment running ahead of proven value:

  • IBM CEO Study (2025): 2,000 CEOs in 33 countries reported that only 25% of AI initiatives met their expected return; 64% fund some technologies before their value is clear for fear of falling behind; 61% are adopting AI agents.
  • PwC (April 2025): 79% of 308 U.S. executives say their companies are already adopting AI agents, and 88% plan to raise AI budgets because of them.
  • Google Cloud (September 2025): 52% of 3,466 senior leaders in 24 countries are using AI agents, and 74% reported a return on generative AI within the first year.

Small Business Spending

  • Thryv (2026): 66% of 561 U.S. small business owners use AI, up from 55% a year earlier; 53% spend at least $100 per month on AI tools.
  • Expected savings: 61% of Thryv respondents expect savings of $500 to $2,000 per month.
  • Pax8 (Q2 2026): 61% of 402 U.S. SMB leaders use AI in operations and 29% are testing it; about 31% of users are stuck between testing and rollout.
  • Policies: only 23% of Pax8 respondents have a written AI use policy.
  • Intuit QuickBooks: only 12% of U.S. businesses paid for dedicated AI tools between 2021 and 2025, but 86% of 2024 payers continued paying in 2025.
  • Training: in the Goldman Sachs 10,000 Small Businesses survey of 1,256 owners, 73% want more AI training.

Agents Beyond Software

Agent research is also moving into the physical world. At Brown University, a robot that combines spoken requests with pointing gestures reached 89% success in simulation, showing how dog behaviour taught a robot to find lost keys.

Workforce Expectations

Microsoft’s 2025 Work Trend Index reported that:

  • 82% of leaders expect to use AI agents to expand workforce capacity within 12 to 18 months;
  • 46% say their organisations already use agents to fully automate workstreams;
  • 71% of workers at AI-first “Frontier Firms” say their company is thriving, compared with 37% globally.

Online Infrastructure for Agent Pilots

Agent pilots in small businesses often start in customer-facing channels such as website chat, booking forms and email follow-up. A dedicated website is a prerequisite for these deployments, and registering cheap .com domains keeps setup costs low while pilots are still being evaluated.

Key Numbers at a Glance

  • 41%: smaller-company leaders piloting agents for decision support.
  • 95%: organisations reporting no measurable return from generative AI spending (MIT NANDA).
  • 40%+: agentic AI projects Gartner expects to be cancelled by 2027.
  • 64%: CEOs funding technologies before their value is clear.
  • 23%: SMBs with a written AI use policy.

Leave a Comment